[
  {"id":"library-hours","category":"Community","motion":"The city should fund a six-month trial of longer evening library hours.","open":"What would make a public library more useful to our community?","define":"Which branches, evenings, budget and six-month evaluation?","for":"Consider access for people who cannot visit during work hours.","against":"Consider staffing costs and whether another service meets the same need.","check":"Check local opening hours, use by time of day and a costed staffing plan."},
  {"id":"car-free-street","category":"Community","motion":"Our town should trial a car-free main street on one Sunday each month.","open":"How should we balance access, local business and public space on our main street?","define":"Which street, hours, access exemptions and trial end date?","for":"Consider space for walking, gathering and local activities.","against":"Consider disabled access, deliveries and displacement of traffic.","check":"Check access needs, traffic counts and feedback from affected businesses."},
  {"id":"participatory-budget","category":"Community","motion":"Our city should let residents allocate a small pilot fund through participatory budgeting.","open":"Who should help decide how a local pilot fund is spent?","define":"What fund, eligibility, voting process and accountability?","for":"Consider residents’ knowledge of priorities and participation.","against":"Consider participation barriers and projects that serve fewer visible groups.","check":"Check comparable program reports, participation and completed-project costs."},
  {"id":"ai-disclosure","category":"Technology","motion":"Organizations should disclose substantial AI assistance in public-facing written advice.","open":"When would knowing that AI helped write something change how you trust it?","define":"Which advice, what counts as substantial assistance and what disclosure?","for":"Consider accountability and informed evaluation by readers.","against":"Consider ambiguous thresholds and whether verification matters more than tools used.","check":"Find concrete examples of helpful and unhelpful disclosures; separate opinion from measured effects."},
  {"id":"phone-free-dinner","category":"Everyday life","motion":"Our household should try phone-free dinners for one month.","open":"What makes time together feel attentive rather than obligatory?","define":"Which dinners, emergency exceptions and a review after the trial?","for":"Consider attention and uninterrupted conversation.","against":"Consider flexibility, care responsibilities and individual preferences.","check":"Ask everyone affected what they need; a preference is not a universal fact."},
  {"id":"repair-first","category":"Everyday life","motion":"Our community group should repair usable equipment before replacing it when the repair is affordable.","open":"How do you decide whether to repair, replace or do without something?","define":"What counts as usable, affordable and safe?","for":"Consider waste reduction and extending useful life.","against":"Consider repair reliability, time and operating costs.","check":"Compare item-specific repair quotes, replacement costs and expected lifetime."},
  {"id":"ai-workplace","category":"Technology","motion":"Teams should document an AI-assisted workflow before making it their default.","open":"What would make an AI-assisted workflow worth trusting at work?","define":"Which tasks, tests, responsible owner and review date?","for":"Consider error discovery, accountability and reproducible procedures.","against":"Consider documentation burden and delaying low-risk improvements.","check":"Compare errors and task completion on the actual workflow, not a general model benchmark."},
  {"id":"notification-default","category":"Technology","motion":"Apps should default optional promotional notifications to off.","open":"Which notifications help you, and which interrupt you without adding value?","define":"Separate promotional messages from security and requested reminders.","for":"Consider user control and fewer unwanted interruptions.","against":"Consider discovering relevant features and easy ways to adjust settings.","check":"Inspect actual notification settings and distinguish opt-in choices from stated preferences."},
  {"id":"four-day-trial","category":"Work","motion":"Our team should trial a four-day workweek for three months without reducing pay.","open":"What would a more sustainable workweek look like for our team?","define":"Which team, total hours, coverage, pay and trial success criteria?","for":"Consider focused work and a sustainable schedule.","against":"Consider coverage, workload compression and role differences.","check":"Check task volumes and coverage requirements; do not infer results from an unrelated company."},
  {"id":"meeting-default","category":"Work","motion":"Our team should replace routine status meetings with written updates unless discussion is needed.","open":"Which meetings are worth having together?","define":"Which meetings, response expectations and a route for urgent questions?","for":"Consider flexible access and protected focus time.","against":"Consider misunderstandings, writing burden and relationship building.","check":"Review actual meeting purposes and whether written updates resolve questions."},
  {"id":"public-art","category":"Community","motion":"Our neighborhood should reserve part of its public-space budget for locally chosen art.","open":"What makes a shared place feel like it belongs to the people using it?","define":"Which budget, selection process, maintenance and accessibility?","for":"Consider expression, identity and inviting shared spaces.","against":"Consider competing maintenance needs and who gets represented.","check":"Compare costed proposals and ask people who use the space, including less-visible groups."},
  {"id":"skill-sharing","category":"Everyday life","motion":"Our community group should hold a monthly free skill-sharing session.","open":"What could we teach each other that would improve everyday life?","define":"Which skills, venue, accessibility and limits on advice requiring qualifications?","for":"Consider practical learning and new local connections.","against":"Consider organizer capacity, demand and quality control.","check":"Collect requested skills and volunteer availability before assuming attendance."}
]